Pricing shape: one ladder, one flat rate
MetalpriceAPI spreads its pricing across eight named tiers, Free through Business Plus, moving from $5/mo at Essential to $132/mo at Business Plus, billed yearly. Metals-API's own page shows a published entry point at $19.99/mo and a production-level rate at $149.99/mo, without the same number of visible middle steps.
For a team that wants to start near-free and step up gradually, MetalpriceAPI's ladder gives more granularity. For a team that already knows it needs the higher tier, Metals-API's flatter structure means fewer plan-comparison decisions along the way.
Coverage: broad catalog vs a named three-metal list
Metals-API's positioning leans on catalog breadth, industrial metals like aluminum, nickel, and zinc sit on the same key as gold. MetalpriceAPI's own FAQ names gold, silver, and platinum specifically as its spot coverage, without an equivalent industrial-metals list in the source we reviewed. Read literally, MetalpriceAPI is the narrower of the two despite both brands leaning on a similar "metals and FX" pitch.
Currency counts sit close: 170+ for Metals-API against 150+ for MetalpriceAPI. Neither gap is likely decisive on its own.
What neither one documents
MetalpriceAPI states outright that it has no WebSocket streaming. Metals-API's page simply doesn't address streaming, so treat that row as unconfirmed rather than a matching no. The same pattern shows up on free-tier detail and overage policy: MetalpriceAPI documents its free tier and stays silent on overage; Metals-API does the reverse. A team that needs a firm answer on either point should check directly with the provider rather than infer it from the other's public page.