Pricing: close at entry, further apart in structure
The two are within a dollar of each other at the bottom, $4.99/mo for GoldAPI.io against $5/mo for MetalpriceAPI's Essential tier. What differs is the shape above that: MetalpriceAPI ladders seven paid tiers up to $132/mo at Business Plus, billed yearly, while GoldAPI.io publishes two, topping out at $129/mo for its production plan. A team that wants small, incremental upgrades gets more of them from MetalpriceAPI's ladder.
The LBMA question
GoldAPI.io states outright that it holds LBMA AM/PM fix redistribution rights, a specific, checkable claim about its data lineage. MetalpriceAPI makes no equivalent public claim, and our own research treated that gap as unverifiable rather than assuming MetalpriceAPI lacks a comparable relationship. Anyone who needs LBMA provenance specifically should confirm directly with MetalpriceAPI rather than infer an answer from silence.
Coverage and history
MetalpriceAPI names platinum alongside gold and silver in its FAQ, one metal GoldAPI.io's page doesn't claim. GoldAPI.io counters with a stated 20+ years of historical depth, a figure MetalpriceAPI's page doesn't publish an equivalent for. Currency counts sit close, 160+ against 150+, not far enough apart to matter on its own.
What neither one documents
Commercial-use terms, WebSocket support, and SDK maintenance status are each documented by one provider and silent on the other's page. GoldAPI.io is explicit about commercial use (permitted on all paid plans) and lists community SDKs; MetalpriceAPI is explicit about not offering WebSocket streaming. Where a row above reads not stated, that's the actual state of the published record, not an oversight in this comparison.