Two different bets on precision
GoldAPI.io bets on depth within a narrow catalog: gold and silver, LBMA fix redistribution rights, and LBMA AM fix (1968+). Metals.dev bets on breadth: nine metals under one key, with LBMA, LME, MCX, and IBJA blended together rather than exposed as separate rows. Neither approach is wrong, they're built for different buyers.
Pricing
For GoldAPI.io, its plan listing shows Sandbox (up to 100 requests/month) and Unlimited ($99/month).
Coverage: narrow vs broad
GoldAPI.io claims the deeper historical record for LBMA AM fix since 1968 against Metals.dev's 5+ years, and Metals.dev caps any single historical request to a 30-day window. Metals.dev wins decisively on catalog width: platinum, palladium, aluminum, copper, nickel, lead, and zinc are all in scope, none of which GoldAPI.io's own comparison page claims to cover.
Source attribution
Metals.dev names its authority sources (a dedicated LBMA/LME/MCX/IBJA endpoint exists) but still returns one blended number per metal without disclosing how the blend is weighted. GoldAPI.io's per-source attribution is not stated in our sources.