A wider rivalry, narrowed to gold
Alpha Vantage and Massive.com (formerly Polygon.io) compete broadly across equities, options, and forex. This page ignores that fight and stays inside gold, silver, and copper coverage, where the two look quite different: one runs a free tier with rate-limit pricing, the other skips free entirely for one flat unlimited plan.
Pricing model
Alpha Vantage's paid tiers meter by rate limit with no monthly cap, $49.99/mo at 75 requests/min scaling to $249.99/mo at 1,200 requests/min. Massive.com charges one flat $49/mo for unlimited streaming and API requests across its whole catalog, gold included. A developer who wants a single, predictable line item leans toward Massive.com; one who wants a free tier to prototype against leans toward Alpha Vantage.
Futures settlement is the clearest gap
Massive.com's documentation confirms gold, silver, and copper futures (GC, SI, HG) on its futures plan. Alpha Vantage's public documentation doesn't call out a futures settlement symbol distinct from spot for gold. If your product needs to resolve against a settlement price specifically, that single fact likely settles the comparison on its own.
Streaming and free access
Alpha Vantage's 25 requests/day free tier gives a working path to prototype without a card. Massive.com has no free tier but bundles unlimited WebSocket streaming into its single $49/mo plan, no separate credits to track. Which one wins depends on whether you value a free on-ramp or a flat, metering-free paid tier more.